the analytics vault
Resources: 136 (72 new this week)
a Hipster Data Club product Hipster Data Club

Picking a tag manager that won't make you cry

Original: Tag Management Systems: How Do I Choose?

May 26, 2025
8 min read
Strategy
Intermediate
Tag management systems: How do I choose?

Summary

An analytics-consultant’s framework for selecting and governing a TMS.

Who This Is For

Marketing Analysts
Technical Marketers
Marketing Ops

Key Takeaways

  • Decide whether you want to remove developers from tagging entirely or just escape slow deployment cycles (spoiler: the latter is more realistic)
  • Choose between synchronous tags (better for testing/optimization) vs asynchronous tags (better for page performance)
  • Evaluate the trade-offs between scalability, speed, and ease-of-use based on your team's specific needs
  • Understand that no single tag management system solves all problems - governance and internal processes matter more than the tool itself

Tools & Technologies

Ensighten Tealium BrightTag Adobe Analytics (SiteCatalyst) Adobe Target (Test&Target) Tag Management Systems (TMS)

Topics Covered

tag-management governance tool-selection