the analytics vault
Resources: 136 (72 new this week)
a Hipster Data Club product Hipster Data Club

Why lumping all your search traffic together is making your data useless

Original: “Paid Search” & “Organic Search” are useless Marketing Channels

Lukas Oldenburg
June 2, 2025
10 min read
Opinion
Intermediate
“Paid Search” & “Organic Search” are useless Marketing Channels

Summary

This article explores why the common marketing channel groupings of 'Paid Search' and 'Organic Search' are too broad and undifferentiated to provide meaningful insights. It delves into the importance of splitting these channels into more granular segments to better understand their unique performance and contribution to the business.

Who This Is For

Marketing Analysts
Performance Marketers
Marketing Managers

Key Takeaways

  • Split 'Paid Search' into Brand, Shopping, and Non-Brand channels for meaningful insights
  • Brand keyword campaigns have dramatically different performance (often 20x cheaper CPC) than other paid search
  • Use manual UTM tagging instead of relying solely on gclid parameters for accurate tracking
  • Separating organic search by intent and keyword types reveals hidden performance patterns
  • Granular channel segmentation prevents high-performing segments from masking poor performers

Tools & Technologies

Google Analytics Adobe Analytics Piwik Pro Amplitude Google Ads Bing Ads UTM parameters gclid tracking

Topics Covered

marketing-channels search-engine-optimization paid-advertising business-strategy

More from Lukas Oldenburg

Related Resources in Business Understanding

Topics

marketing-channels search-engine-optimization paid-advertising business-strategy